Dr Hafiz Ahmed Saeed Rana, and Muhammad Sohail. “The Four Stages of Sufism: A Historical-Philosophical Reading of the Transformations of Spiritual Conduct: أطوار التَّصوُّف الأربعة: قراءة تاريخية فلسفية لتحوّلات السلوك الرُّوحي”. Al-Bahis Journal of Islamic Sciences Research " Y &Quot; Catagory, vol. 6, no. 2, Dec. 2025, pp. 42-49, https://brjisr.com/index.php/brjisr/article/view/256.